i-capitalNews2 min read

Cover letter to the annual financial statements: relevance for rating & credit assessment

Entrepreneurs and banks read the same annual financial statements from completely different perspectives. A cover letter ensures the right interpretation.

What is a cover letter to the annual financial statements?

The cover letter is a separate document that gives readers of the annual financial statements important context. Information is explained in a way that suits the audience and is put in the right light. Often, the framework and interpretation are just as important as the core message itself – especially because entrepreneurs and banks or rating agencies look at the same financial statements very differently.

Classifying one-off income correctly

Some transactions – such as insurance payments for costs incurred or prior-period income – are compensation for costs already incurred from the entrepreneur's point of view. For banks, however, exactly these items tend to be deducted, because analysts are not familiar with the circumstances.

From the perspective of an outside third party, they are one-off income in case of doubt – but banks focus on sustainable earning power: is the company able to repay the loan from its operating business without special effects?

The added value of an externally prepared cover letter lies in classifying such items. If insurance compensation is offset by corresponding costs, from the bank's perspective either both the extraordinary income and the extraordinary expenses must be eliminated, or both retained – the net contribution to earnings, and thus the assessment of debt service capacity, does not change. The example shows that correct classification can have a significant impact on a company's rating.

A good rating – shaped proactively

The cover letter also includes an indicative rating – ideally before the reporting date, based on forecast figures and relevant earnings, balance sheet and liquidity ratios.

This allows optimisation potential to be identified and implemented early on: entrepreneurs influence their rating proactively instead of reacting to a poor rating for the next financial year. As the large number of rating ratios makes optimisation demanding, measures and their effect on the rating can be simulated:

Short term

For example, paying liabilities just before the end of the financial year in order to report the highest possible equity ratio on the reporting date.

Medium term

For example, gradually switching from leasing to hire purchase to increase EBITDA.

An indicative rating also helps in the annual meeting with financing partners: if you have dealt with the issues intensively in advance, it is easier to convince them where facts can be interpreted differently.

Keyword: debt service capacity

For banks, debt service capacity is one of the most important ratios. Operating profit is adjusted for non-cash effects to determine operating cash flow, which is then compared with the debt service due – i.e. interest and principal payments.

This, too, can be simulated as part of the rating and backed up with improvement measures. A timely debt service analysis is important so that countermeasures can take effect before the reporting date. Find out more: integrated corporate planning.

Your contact

Philip HerrmannPartner, i-capital